ENGL 3130 Business Writing

This artifact was composed for ENGL 3130: Business Writing with Professor Swirsky in Spring 2026. The assignment required us to take on a role within a company or organization, identify a specific audience, and create a clear and comprehensive report addressing a particular issue. My intended audience was the employees of Penguin Random House, and the genre was a problem-solving analytical report.

I selected this artifact because it reflects my development beyond writing traditional academic essays. This assignment gave me the opportunity to conduct research with a practical purpose and use that research to address a real-world problem within the publishing industry. It also connects closely to my interest in book publishing and allowed me to write for a professional audience rather than only an academic one.

One of the report’s greatest strengths was its outline and overall structure, which helped me organize the information and present the problem and proposed solution clearly. If I were to revise it, I would improve some of the wording to make the report more polished and professional. I would also find additional sources to strengthen the research and provide more support for my recommendations.

Analytical Problem-Solving Report

To: Penguin Random House’s Editorial & Digital Innovation Committee [Editorial Director, Managing Editor, Head of Digital Strategy, Global AI Lead, Head of Rights & Contracts]

From: Camille McCraw, Editorial Strategy Associate, PRH

Subject: Establishing a Structured AI Framework for Publishing Operations

Date: March 13, 2026

As requested by the Editorial & Digital Innovation Committee, I am emailing the following proposal because PRH has strong ethical principles regarding AI, but lacks a clearly structured operational framework for implementing AI across publishing workflows. And if left unresolved, we would be compromising our editorial standards, authors’ trust, and our reputation as a Big Five publishing house would be at risk. My purpose here is to evaluate how artificial intelligence can be adopted more responsibly. We look forward to your response on the matter. Please contact my associates or me if you have any questions! [see the attached file below]

Summary/Introduction:

Penguin Random House has already acknowledged that artificial intelligence is becoming part of modern publishing and has publicly protected copyright and authors’ rights, but is still navigating how generative AI fits into publishing operations. Without consistent internal guidelines, AI adoption may vary across teams, posing risks to author trust, editorial quality, and the company’s reputation. This report examines that gap and recommends implementing a structured AI governance framework aligned with Pan Macmillan’s strategy, which outlines approved use cases, requires human oversight, and reinforces transparency with authors and agents.

Criteria for Evaluating Solutions: 

Our Principles: 

  1. Advocate & Protect author trust and intellectual property. (PRH)
  2. Maintain human creativity & editorial quality standards. (PRH)
  3. Align with public ethical commitments. (PRH)

Analysis of Possible Solutions:

Option 1: Maintain Current Protective Strategy - PRH would continue focusing primarily on limiting AI use and protecting intellectual property without introducing formal operational guidelines.

  • Advantages:
    • Maintains a strong ethical stance.
    • Protects authors from potential misuse.
  • Limitations: 
    • Employees lack clarity about acceptable uses of AI tools.
    • The company may fall behind competitors experimenting with structured AI integration.
    • Opportunities for workflow efficiency remain underdeveloped.

Option 2: Full Integration of AI Across Publishing Processes - PRH could adopt a highly aggressive AI adoption strategy.

  • Advantages:
    • Increased operational efficiency.
    • Competitive technological advantage
  • Limitations: 
    • Potential damage to author trust.
    • Risk of undermining editorial standards.
    • Conflicts with the company’s commitment to protecting creative labor.

Option 3: Structured AI Governance Framework (Recommended) - This approach balances innovation and ethical responsibility through clearly defined policies.

Key elements would include:

  • Human Oversight Requirements - Editorial and marketing staff review all AI-generated outputs.
  • Transparency Standards (approach to AI at Pan Macmillan) - Clear communication with authors and agents about operational AI use.
  • Internal Training Programs - Staff educated on ethical and responsible AI practices (Pan Macmillan launches)

Drawbacks would include:

  • The Expenses: Developing policies, training staff, and assigning oversight roles may require additional time and financial resources.
  • Slow to Adopt: Required guidelines and human-review processes may slow experimentation with new AI tools relative to competitors.
  • Frequent Updates to Policy: AI technology evolves quickly, so governance guidelines would need regular revisions to remain effective.

Comparative Industry Example:

Pan Macmillan provides a useful reference point because the company has begun implementing structured AI practices while maintaining human-centered publishing values.

Their approach:

  • Improve operational efficiency and innovation.
  • Internal AI training programs
    • “Pan Macmillan has launched a new AI Academy for colleagues, as part of a push to upskill its people and build a more sustainable publishing industry. Training will be provided by Multiverse to 20 colleagues across departments - including colleagues from editorial to finance, design and operations - helping them deliver more effective service to authors and illustrators through responsible AI use.” (Pan Macmillan launches new AI skills)
  • This example suggests that a balanced framework is both practical and achievable.

Conclusion:

In summary, AI is becoming a permanent feature of the publishing industry. Penguin Random House has taken an important role in advocating for author rights and the protection of all intellectual property. The company’s current approach focuses primarily on restriction rather than structured implementation. As a result, the organization faces uncertainty about how to use AI in everyday operations. Adopting a structured AI governance framework would allow Penguin Random House to shift from a defensive stance to a balanced strategy that protects creative work while responsibly embracing innovation and efficiency.

Recommendation:

Based on the analysis and example above, Penguin Random House should implement a formal AI governance framework that provides clear operational guidance while reinforcing the company’s commitment to ethical publishing.

Works Cited

“Our approach to AI at Pan Macmillan”, Pan Macmillan. Copyright 2025.  

https://www.panmacmillan.com/ai-at-pan-macmillan 

“Pan Macmillan launches new AI skills training to better connect books and readers”, Pan 

Macmillan. 3 March 2026. Copyright 2025. https://www.panmacmillan.com/news/pan-macmillan-launches-new-ai-skills-training.

“Penguin’s approach to generative artificial intelligence”, Penguin Random House, 8 August 2024. Copyright 2025. https://www.penguin.co.uk/discover/articles/penguins-approach-to-generative-artificial-intelligence.

Create Your Own Website With Webador