ENGL 3090 Exposition

This artifact was composed for ENGL 3090: Exposition: HIST, THRY, PRCT in Fall 2025 with Dr. Slaky. The assignment required students to select a myth from any culture and retell it using an expository writing style. To do this, we first had to reconsider the myth’s significance and develop a researchable argument or focal point around it. My essay focused on the contemporary myth of Mrs. Claus, examining her character as a symbol of equality, leadership, and empowerment.

The genre of this assignment was an expository essay, and its purpose was to develop a deeper understanding of holiday traditions while reimagining Mrs. Claus beyond her traditional role in Santa Claus lore. My intended audience was people who celebrate Christmas or readers who are interested in the stories and traditions surrounding Santa Claus. I selected this artifact because it represents one of the more niche topics I explored at GSU, and I genuinely enjoyed researching Mrs. Claus and her place within the holiday tradition. I have always been interested in contemporary myths, particularly those surrounding holidays, and this topic allowed me to explore larger questions about gender, visibility, and the roles assigned to women in familiar stories.

One of the essay’s greatest strengths was the quality and depth of its content. I particularly valued examining how the myth of Mrs. Claus has changed over time and how different interpretations emphasize aspects of her character that are often overlooked. Comparing classic and modern versions helped me develop a more complete understanding of her role. I was also inspired by Natalie Haynes’ writing, especially her use of rhetorical questions to encourage readers to pause and reconsider familiar ideas. If I were to revise the essay, I would refine some of the language and writing style to make the expository voice feel more natural. Because I am more accustomed to academic writing, incorporating personal pronouns and my own perspective on Mrs. Claus initially felt unfamiliar. I would revise those personal elements so they contribute meaningfully to the discussion while preserving the essay’s explanatory and informative purpose.

Retell a Myth – The Myth of Mrs. Claus

Ho! Ho! Ho! Everyone recognizes Santa’s booming greeting, but far fewer people stop to wonder about the woman standing beside him. With Santa filling up people’s December traditions, it’s easy to forget that Mrs. Claus, his partner who helps run the North Pole, has barely been given a story of her own. In earlier myths, she is typically depicted in a brief cameo or description, doing everything in her power to support her husband, and this is conveyed solely through household chores. However, moving beyond such a traditional view, modern interpretations portray Mrs. Claus as her own person. The purpose of this comparison is to examine how her character is underdeveloped, offering an opportunity to explore how she reflects changing ideas about gender roles. Although often overlooked, the myth of Mrs. Claus evolved from a domestic background figure to a symbol of female leadership and empowerment, revealing how cultural narratives adapt to modern values and expectations. 

 

The very first story to mention Santa Claus’ wife is A Christmas Legend (1849) by James Rees. The tale begins with a family of four appreciating the spirit of Christmas, until an older man and woman, both carrying bundles on their backs, are given shelter by a kind family on Christmas Eve. The next morning, the children awake to find an abundance of gifts left behind, and the mysterious visitors are revealed to be not “old Santa Claus and his wife,” but the hosts’ long-lost daughter and her husband in disguise (Reese). Although Mrs. Claus in this story is not yet the warm, cookie-baking figure we recognize today, her appearance introduces the idea of Santa having a companion and partner in generosity. Over time, Mrs. Claus never developed a single, definitive identity; her first name varies with each retelling. James Reese started this by giving her the name Gertrude. You might think this name would stick, since she doesn’t have a traditional name like Santa’s, who is known as good old (Saint) Nicholas. But no over time, she has also been called Jessica, Mary, Anna, Amelia, and even Carol in different stories, movies, and books. This fluidity shows that she isn’t tied to one specific myth but instead shifts between multiple versions, adapting to the cultural imagination of each era.

 

Jumping forward approximately thirty years, a poem titled “Mistress Santa Claus” by Margaret Eytinge introduces one of the first classic images of what Mrs. Claus should look like. Eytinge describes her as “small and plump,” with “brown and bright” eyes, and constantly busy “from morn till night” assisting the elves and preparing gifts for children. This depiction establishes her as the cheerful, industrious wife whose primary purpose is to support Santa’s mission. Another significant early portrayal appears in M. B. Horton’s 1897 story published in Godey’s Lady’s Book. In this version, Mrs. Claus secretly leaves the North Pole while Santa sleeps, too eager to deliver gifts on her own. However, the narrative quickly undercuts her independence. She is introduced with a dismissive remark about her plain clothing, suggesting that she lacks a “weak woman’s regard for fashion”, and the plot ultimately frames her attempt at agency as misguided (Davis). Santa, after he realizes his wife’s plans, deliberately sabotages her efforts by switching her bag of gifts for one filled with broken and unwanted items, ensuring her delivery disappoints the children. Unaware, Mrs. Claus leaves the North Pole. Once she reaches the first gift drop-off location and opens the bag, she finds nothing suitable to give the kids. A wave of self-doubt washes over her, leading to the painful conclusion that she is to blame, causing her to cry uncontrollably. Santa then arrives and surprises her with the real presents, restoring her joy and his authority. By the end, Mrs. Claus profusely apologizes to her husband and accepts that her proper role is to forgive and to remain the devoted, supportive wife. Echoing the sentiments of Davis, but “forgive me if I find this Christmas story a little less than heart-warming”. After all, these early illustrations of Mrs. Claus confine her to the domestic expectations of a baker, a nagging wife, and a housekeeper, because a woman with independence was still seen as rebellious. Overall, traditional media reinforces the idea that women in stories support men’s journeys rather than have their own.

 

Yet, as cultural attitudes about women’s roles began to shift, later stories and films started to reimagine Mrs. Claus in new ways for Christmas. For starters, the iconic 1963 children's book How Mrs. Santa Claus Saved Christmas by Phyllis McGinley remimagines her character with more power and visibility. The story begins with a disagreement between the married couple, where Mrs. Claus has an idea for Christmas that Mr. Claus finds so impossible that it makes him ill. And so, while Santa is sleeping on Christmas Eve to recover, Mrs. Claus sees her chance to implement her idea while Santa is asleep. Her big plan is for children to receive presents that represent their "untold wishes of their hearts," effectively saving Christmas from being a disappointment and ensuring it is filled with genuine joy. As a reader, one would think: Is that it? Why isn’t there more? And I would have to agree. Comparing this to traditional myths, the story is very similar to M.B. Horton’s version, but the main difference is that Mrs. Claus was able to give the gifts this time without Santa's interference. In other words, McGinely wrote with a clear feminist lens, making her deliver gifts, run the workshop, and become the new Santa for a night. However, it's still tame, suggesting that even when Mrs. Claus is allowed to step into the spotlight, it’s only a partial break from the long-established domestic expectations placed on her.

 

This modern shift becomes even more visible in contemporary media. In The Christmas Chronicles: Part Two, Goldie Hawn’s Mrs. Claus plays a much more active and prominent role, contributing to problem-solving, crafting magic, and shaping the narrative rather than simply supporting Santa from the sidelines. Real-world cultural changes mirror this evolution as well. In 2023, Sheryl Lee Ralph became the first celebrity and the first Black woman to portray Mrs. Claus in the Macy’s Thanksgiving Day Parade, marking a significant expansion of who is allowed to embody the myth (Wikipedia). These newer portrayals contrast sharply with earlier interpretations, which confined Mrs. Claus to the domestic sphere because, as Davis explains, “Christmas is a home-centered holiday. Who was going to cook the big meals? Wrap the presents? Decorate the house? Clean up before guests arrive and again after guests leave? Certainly not the man of the house.” Modern retellings challenge this outdated assumption by placing Mrs. Claus at the center of the action, granting her agency, leadership, and the authority that earlier stories denied her.

 

After examining both traditional and modern interpretations of Mrs. Claus, the clear evolution of her character is culturally significant to perspectives on womanhood and partnership. It may seem surprising that a myth about a cheerful, holly-jolly wife could illuminate issues of inequality and the constraints of traditional gender roles, yet Mrs. Claus does precisely that. Her shifting portrayals reveal how stories adapt to changing social values, creating space for female figures in classic myths to be seen not as wallflowers or dutiful sidekicks, but as individuals with compelling narratives of their own. In this way, the expansion of Mrs. Claus into what some call “the holiday superwoman” is more than a modern embellishment; it serves as an essential step toward broader representation, especially in the stories that shape children’s early ideas about gender, power, and possibility (Marling). All in all, researching this contemporary myth in greater depth highlights the important conversation about gender and invisibility. 

 

Ultimately, reimagining Mrs. Claus is about more than giving a familiar holiday figure a personality upgrade; it’s about challenging the outdated cultural norms that have long limited women in myth and media. When Mrs. Claus steps out of the background and becomes a fully realized partner, leader, or hero, she opens the door for girls to see themselves as central to the stories that shape their world. By embracing a Mrs. Claus who is capable, dynamic, and essential to the narrative, we not only enrich the myth itself but also support a broader cultural shift toward equality and representation. Her evolving story shows that even the most familiar myths can grow to reflect new possibilities.

Works Cited

Davis, Lori. “Mrs. Santa Claus”, Her Half of History. 5 December 2024.  https://herhalfofhistory.com/2024/12/05/mrs-santa-claus/. 

Eytinge, Margaret. “Mistress Santa Claus”, Harper's Yong People: Christmas Number. Harper & Brothers, 20 December 1881. https://www.gutenberg.org/files/50545/50545-h/50545-h.htm. 

Marling, Karal Ann. “The Revenge of Mrs. Santa Claus or Martha Stewart Does Christmas.”American Studies, vol. 42, no. 2, 2001, pp. 133–38. JSTOR, http://www.jstor.org/stable/40643258. Accessed 7 Nov. 2025.

“Mrs. Claus”, Wikipedia: The Free Encyclopedia. Last edited on 6 April 2025.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mrs._Claus.  

Reese, James. “A Christmas Legend”, Santa’s Whiskers. J.W. Moore Publishing, 1849, pp. 

91-100  http://www.santaswhiskers.com/a-christmas-legend.html.